Publishing: Trigueiro Fontes Advogados Previous Versions
January 2010
Number: XXXXVI


By reason of the agreement entered into by the National Justice Council (CNJ), the Ministry of Sports and the Brazilian Organization Committee of the 2014 World Cup, prisoners, ex-prisoners and teenagers in conflict with the law shall be hired to act in the works for completion of the sporting event in the bidding processes related to games.

In hearing of appeal, the 1st Panel of the STJ (Superior Justice Court) decided the controversial question about the legal nature of the consideration and limitation period for water and sewerage taxes.

In the stock market, the concern about weather changes led to the creation of the Carbon Efficient Index by the BM&BOVESPA, which shall measure the efficiency of emissions of gases, which cause the greenhouse effect (GHG), from publicly traded companies.
 
   

TAX LAW

Double period for tax refund

For the 1st Panel of the STJ, the limitation period for answering the tax refund of values unduly paid before the effectiveness of the Complementary Law 118/05, on 06.09.2005, is of 10 years, provided that, on the date of effectiveness of the law, not more than five years as from the limitation period remain. However, in case of unduly payments made after the effectiveness of the law, the period of five years begins as from the date of payment. (REsp 1002932)

ICMS (Tax on the Circulation of Goods and on Services of Interstate and Intermunicipal Transportation and Communication) differential on construction shall not be collected

The STJ decided that the civil construction companies, when purchasing materials in other states to be used as inputs in the works performed, are not subject to the collection of ICMS differential tax rate charged by the recipient state. The civil construction is an activity of exclusive relevance to services subject to the levy of ISS (municipal services tax). Therefore, any goods necessary for this activity, such as machinery, equipment, fixed assets, materials and parts, shall not be defined as goods subject to state tax. (REsp 1135489)

The nature of water and sewerage taxes was defined

The 1st Section of the STJ decided that the consideration for water and sewerage services is not related to tax charges, because it concerns tax or public price legal nature, being not submitted to the tax legal regime set out for the taxes, and its limitation period is governed by the Civil Code. (Resp 1117903)

 

 

LABOR LAW

Sick pay shall not interrupt limitation period

The suspension of the employment agreement due to the receipt of the social security benefit shall not result in the suspension of the limitation period for claiming labor rights in court, by reason of absence of legal provision for that. With this decision, the 5th Panel of the TST dismissed the appeal of a worker against decision of the TRT of the 18th Region. (RR-1.215/2007-009-18-00.1)

5 minutes of risk a day leads to dangerous work
An employee in charge of exchanging gas cylinders twice a day has accrued the right to receive the premium for dangerous work. The minister Aloysio Corrêa da Veiga, from the 6th Panel of the TST, heard the appeal against Precedent 364 of the TST, taking into account the content of the expert evidence. (RR-145-2007-051-18-00.0)

Arbitration is only allowed after the termination of the agreement
When the employee does not work for the company any longer, his/her vulnerability is reduced and, therefore, disputes may be settled by arbitration. The 4th Panel of the TST decided that the Chamber of Settlement and Arbitration of Minas Gerais shall not settle labor disputes only when an arbitration clause has been the object of an employment agreement or amendment to the agreement during the effectiveness of the employment relationship. (RR - 259/2008-075-03-00)

The Federal Government undertakes to pay expert fees in AJG

Considering that the Federal Constitution determines that the State shall provide free legal assistance to people with insufficient financial resources (Article 5, LXXIV), the Federal Government shall pay such expenditures, including the expert fees, that is what the 1st Panel of the TST has decided. Therefore, the free legal assistance also applies to the expert fees, because the expert shall not be charged for that, under penalty of devaluation of his/her work. (RR- 204/1999-001-17-00.8)

 

STF’S PRECEDENT

PSV 29 - The STF accepted, by majority vote, the proposal for the Biding Precedent 29 with the following content: "It is not defined as a material crime against the tax regime, provided in article 1, item I, of Law No. 8137/90, before the final release of the tax”.

BUSINESS LAW

The STJ overrules restriction for enrollment at the CNPJ (Brazilian Register of Corporate Taxpayers).

The enrollment and data update at the Brazilian Register of Corporate Taxpayers (CNPJ) shall be guaranteed to all companies duly organized, without regulation restrictions which may obstruct the exercise of free enterprise and full development of their economic activities. The decision is from the 1st Section of the STJ in hearing of appeal, for which the obligations required by IN SRF 200/02 surpassed the scope of Law No. 5614/70 concerning instrument of unlawful coercion. (REsp 1103009)

CIVIL LAW

Failure to decide about attorney fees in convictions shall not be remedied by individual action.

If the court fails to establish attorney fees and the judgment becomes unappealable, the attorney fees shall not be charged by individual action, because it would violate the principle of claim preclusion. The judge-rapporteur dismissed the appeal, stating that it would be possible to deal with the issue of attorney fees only by means of relief from judgment. (REsp 886178) 

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW

Bidding processes for the World Cup shall require hiring of prisoners

The National Justice Council (CNJ), the Ministry of Sports and the Brazilian Organization Committee of the 2014 World Cup signed an agreement for prisoners, ex-prisoners and teenagers in conflict with the law to be hired to act in the works for completion of the sporting event. Under the agreement, all companies which participate in the biding processes for works related to games shall allocate 5% of the vacancies for the people included in the program “Começar de Novo” of the National Justice Council, if these companies hire more than 20 people.

ENVIRONMENTAL LAW

Stock exchange shall have index to measure efficiency of GHG emissions

BM&BOVESPA and BNDES (Brazilian Bank of Economic and Social Development) announced the creation of the Carbon Efficient Index, which measures the efficiency of emissions of gases from publicly traded companies, which causes the greenhouse effect (GHG). The index shall probably be released at the end of 2010 and shall initially cover the IBrX-50, which is an index comprised of the 50 most traded shares on BM&BOVESPA, composed of the inventory of GHG emissions made by those companies.

Resolution from CONAMA about contaminated areas was published
 
The resolution No. 420 from the National Council of the Environment (CONAMA) is in force, which provides criteria and guiding values of soil quality regarding the presence of chemicals and establishes guidelines for environmental management of contaminated areas due to human activities.

 

On this month, the article “OS JUROS LEGAIS NA INTERPRETAÇÃO DO SUPERIOR TRIBUNAL DE JUSTIÇA” (“LEGAL INTEREST ACCORDING TO THE SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE”),written by our member Carlos Eduardo Jar e Silva, is available on the website www.trigueirofontes.com.br.
 
 

 

(i)            Taking Office in OAB/PE

Ana Carolina F. de Melo Brito (ANA) and Ana Luiza P. Duarte (ALD), from Recife/PE, took office as State Councilors, along with the new President of the Section from Pernambuco of OAB (Brazilian Bar Association), Dr. Henrique Mariano. 

(ii)           The best Article of the year is from Rio de Janeiro!

With the theme "Arbitragem na solução de conflitos trabalhistas" (“Arbitration to settle labor disputes”), Paula Leonor Mendes Fernandes Rocha (PFR), attorney-at-law from the unit of Rio de Janeiro, won the contest for the "Best Article of the Year - 2009", sponsored by the Office. At second position, Carlos Rosemberg Fernandes Jr (CRJ), from Natal, won with the theme "Energia eólica: os bons ventos que sopram no Rio Grande do Norte" (“Wind power: good winds that blow in Rio Grande do Norte”). Manoel Duarte Pinto (MDP), from Fortaleza, stayed at third position with the theme "Duas breves notas sobre aquisição de imóveis rurais" (“Two short notes on acquisition of rural property”).

(iii)          7th Environmental Conference in São Paulo

Ana Carolina F. de Melo Brito , reviser of the civil and environmental themes,  attended the 7th Environmental Conference in São Paulo, sponsored by IBC- International Business Communication, about “Novas Determinações Legais Aplicadas a Compensação Ambiental, Reserva Legal, Emissões de Gases e Gases Reciclagem de Resíduos” (“New legal requirements applied to Environmental Compensation, Legal Reserve, Emissions of Gases and gases of recycling of waste”).

(iv)          Environmental Damage under discussion in Europe

The member Ana Carolina F. de Melo Brito went to Portugal to attend the I Symposium on Environmental Damage, held at the Law School of Lisbon, where the implementation and internalization of the European directive on environmental damage was discussed, as well as the legal treatment of the theme in the U.S.A and Brazil.

(v)           Conference of Civil Law in Brasília/DF

Daniela Moreira Sampaio Ribeiro (RIB) and Silvia Helena Marçal (SIL), respectively member and coordinator of the team from Brasilia, attended the Conference of Civil Law in Brasília.

(vi)          Juliana Rocha is elected to the Regional Council of AMCHAM/PE

After the position of chairman of the Trade American Chamber legislation committee_PE, Juliana Rocha, a member responsible for the team in Recife, was elected regional councilor of AMCHAM/PE for the next biennium. Before Juliana Rocha, Roberto Trigueiro Fontes had already been chairman of the Council from 2004 to 2007 and currently holds the office of honorary councilor.

(vii)         Conference about Competition law in Rio de Janeiro/RJ

Rodrigo da Fonseca Chauvet (RFC), from the Regional Unit of Rio de Janeiro, attended the 4th Conference about Competition Law, organized by the Brazilian Institute for Competition, Consumption and International Trade Studies (IBRAC) in partnership with the University of the State of Rio de Janeiro (UERJ).

(viii)        Published on LEX

Fábio de Possídio Egashira, senior member of the Office and reviser of arbitration/civil themes, wrote an article under the title “O LAUDO ARBITRAL ESTRANGEIRO E SUA HOMOLOGAÇÃO NO STJ” (“THE FOREIGN ARBITRATION REPORT AND ITS RATIFICATION IN STJ”), available on the website LEX (www.lex.com.br), among other important texts.

 

 
 

EDITORIAL BOARD formed by the members: Carlos Rosemberg Fernandes Jr. Rodrigo da Fonseca Chauvet and Carlos Eduardo Jar e Silva, coordinated by the member Ana Carolina F. de Melo Brito. The information disclosed herein shall not necessarily represent the opinion of the Office. The disclosure is restricted to the clients of the Office or people related to it. The Disclosure is authorized provided that its source is indicated.

 
What do you want to do?
 
    
 
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED - ® - TRIGUEIRO FONTES ADVOGADOS
 
Recife | Salvador | Fortaleza | Natal | São Paulo | Rio de Janeiro | Manaus | Belo Horizonte | Brasília | Porto Alegre | Curitiba
© 2008 Trigueiro Fontes Advogados - All rights reserved